How Are Waste Management Tenders Scored? Understanding MEAT and Quality Criteria

Waste Management
Thea Phillips
October 24, 2025
An orange semi-truck is being loaded with waste by a large yellow CAT excavator inside a spacious industrial recycling facility, next to a massive pile of sorted plastic bags and debris

Many waste management providers assume that successful tendering depends mainly on offering the lowest price. Councils, housing providers and other organisations are certainly working with tight budgets, but in practice, tenders are rarely awarded on cost alone. Buyers are looking to appoint contractors who will deliver reliable, sustainable and safe waste management services as well as value for money.

Regardless of industry, many buyers use the MEAT system (Most Economically Advantageous Tender), which balances cost with a range of quality considerations, totalling an overall value.

Understanding how this works and how buyers tend to structure their evaluation can help contractors to prepare stronger waste management tender submissions and avoid some of the common mistakes leading to lost marks. This blog will walk you through the MEAT system and the likely ways buyers will be scoring your submissions.

A close-up of a person in a suit handing a document and a pen to another person whose hands are clasped on a white table

What Does MEAT Mean?

The MEAT framework is designed to prevent contracts from being awarded solely to the cheapest bidder. Instead, it weighs price against other criteria that offer different types of value, such as service reliability, environmental sustainability, technical capability and compliance with waste management regulations.

The balance between cost and quality varies depending on the contract, but common divides are:

  • 60% Quality / 40% Pricing
  • 70% Quality / 30% Pricing

In the waste management sector, quality is often valued higher than cost because of the consequences of poor service. Missed collections, overflowing bins, and health and safety breaches are all visible and reputational hazards to public safety that buyers cannot afford to risk.

How Price is Scored

Pricing is typically carried out using a relative formula – the lowest compliant bid will receive maximum marks available for cost and all other bids will be scored proportionally against it.

For example, if the lowest bidder offers an annual price of £1 million, they will receive 100% of price marks. If another bidder submits a price of £1.2 million, their score will be calculated as £1 million divided by £1.2 million (0.83), giving them 33.3% out of 40, assuming the pricing is weighted at 40%.

Be careful setting prices too low – this can raise suspicion and if deemed abnormally low, can indicate that suppliers have miscalculated prices or are using morally questionable means to keep costs low.

In waste management tenders, underpricing may lead to unsafe practices, insufficient staffing levels or an inability to meet promised recycling targets. Buyers are looking for sustainable prices that demonstrate efficiency rather than short-term cost cutting.

A vast, sprawling field covered in a dense layer of plastic waste, colorful wrappers, and discarded debris under bright sunlight

Quality Criteria in Waste Tenders

The quality section is where suppliers can distinguish themselves and sell their services. Responses are usually scored on a scale (e.g. 0-5), with higher marks awarded to the most well-evidenced, detailed answers.

Typical quality criteria include:

  • Service delivery and reliability – how collections will be carried out consistently, contingency planning for breakdowns or staff shortages and how missed collections will be resolve
  • Health and safety – systems, staff training and monitoring processes to manage the risks associated with waste handling and vehicle operations.
  • Environmental sustainability – reducing landfill, improving recycling rates, adopting circular economy practices and cutting carbon emissions in line with national net zero object
  • Technology and innovation – use of smart bins, vehicle tracking, real-time reporting apps or client dashboards to improve efficiency and sustainability.
  • Workforce training and wellbeing – support and development through apprenticeships, qualifications, wellbeing initiatives and career pathways.
  • Customer service – handling complaints, maintaining communication channels and measuring customer satisfaction.

A strong response will go beyond general statements – it will prioritise evidencing commitments, using detail to describe systems and programmes and demonstrating measurable value for the buyer.

For example, rather than saying "we use technology to improve service", describe the system you use, how it tracks collections, what data it produces and what measurable improvements it has delivered in past waste management contracts.

Common Pitfalls

Waste management suppliers often lose marks because they:

  • Submit generic responses that do not address the exact question.
  • Focus too heavily on price without demonstrating service quality or innovation.
  • Make claims without evidence such as KPIs or case studies.
  • Provide vague descriptions of processes instead of step-by-step explanations.
Close-up of a person's hands as they use a pen to sign a white document on a dark desk

Tips for Maximising Scores

To maximise success, consider the following tips when writing your next waste management bid:

  • Align your effort with the published weightings in the ITT and spend more time on the highest-scoring sections.
  • Provide clear, structured explanations of processes and contingency measures.
  • Support claims with data, KPIs, case studies and accreditations.
  • Highlight where you deliver added value, such as improved recycling rates, use of digital systems or investment in modern waste collection fleets.
  • Keep answers specific and avoid generic statements.

Final Thoughts

Waste management tenders are scored using MEAT, which ensures contracts are awarded based on a fair balance of cost and quality. Buyers are looking for assurance that providers can deliver reliable and sustainable services at a competitive price.

For contractors, success comes from combining competitive yet realistic pricing with well-evidenced quality responses. For writing assistance or guidance, get in touch with Bid Writing Service and secure your winning chances in future waste management tenders.

Have a waste management tender submission coming up? Why not utilise our expert tender writers? Contact us at michael.baron@bidwritingservice.com or lauren.moorhouse@bidwritingservice.com to discuss your needs, or,fill out the form below!

You May Also Like

Explore more insights and success strategies from our experts.

What Our
Clients Say

See how we’ve helped SMEs across industries secure contracts and grow their success.

S

Syed Hasan

Accounts Manager

We engaged Bid Writing Service to support our submission for the GMC tender, aiming to drive potential growth for our business. While we are still awaiting the final outcome, we can confidently say the service has been excellent and well worth the investment. Special thanks to Jessica, Peter, and Francesca, whose professionalism, responsiveness, and attention to detail greatly contributed to the strength of our submission. Their collaborative approach and expertise made the entire process smooth and reassuring. Highly recommended for any organisation seeking expert bid support.

O

Office Staff

I recently had the pleasure of working with BWS on a bid, and I wanted to share my overwhelmingly positive experience. Their expertise and guidance were truly exceptional and instrumental in our success. Throughout the entire process, BWS provided unwavering support and demonstrated an impressive depth of industry knowledge. I genuinely believe their contributions were the key to our successful bid. Without hesitation, I would wholeheartedly recommend BWS and certainly plan to collaborate with them again in the future.

A

Andrew Hobbs

We engaged Bid Writing Service to support us in responding to a public tender opportunity. The service provided was simply exceptional. Well organised, proactive and responsive, accurate, punctual and of course very well written. This is a quality company with some really excellent client facing members of staff. Thank you Rhiannon, Francesca, Thea, Georgia and Lauren. Brilliant first impression and thoroughly recommended !!

J

Joseph Palmer

We've been working with Lauren and Rhiannon at Bid Writing Service for a few months now and they have been great! They are super responsive to emails and are always there to guide/support us through the process. As soon as a tender get released that matches our industry Lauren sends it straight over even if it's an evening or weekend so we have piece of mind knowing we won't miss any tenders! Thank you Lauren & Rhiannon

R

Ross Nicholson

Rhiannon was very switched on when it came to giving our company advice around bid writing. She produced drafts in a swift and professional manner which was important to us when the deadline was approaching fast.

V

Vanessa Varoujian

Incredibly professional, responsive and dedicated. Great to have a team who take the time to get to know the business and our ethos, and understand the pressures of tender and bid writing for a small organisation.

V

Vinceo Ferlita

Crown ices Ltd.

One of the best companies we have worked with. From our first conversation to the completed work. Always on hand for any questions we had, very knowledgeable and timely. Would use again and would highly recommend. Thank you for your hard work and such excellent service. Crown ices Ltd.

J

James Barber

I can not recommend BWS highly enough. Our first call with Luke was professional and built an immediate trust in the business. Lauren then took on our project at short notice with a 48 hour turn around time. She went above and beyond to ensure it was completed on time. We are now going to have a conversation about building a bid library and them becoming our exclusive supplier.

C

Chris C

Lauren from BWS went above and beyond to support us with our tender on extremely short notice. Her dedication, professionalism, and willingness to assist at all hours were second to none. Lauren's expertise and responsiveness made what could have been a stressful process smooth and efficient. I cannot recommend her highly enough for anyone needing reliable and high-quality support.

G

GMS SERVICES LTD

We have used BWS to assist with our bid writing services. Not only does this provide us with vital resources when there are multiple tenders we want to bid for, it also provides a quality bid which is written by engaging bid writers who are interested in our business and helping us succeed. They become a part of our business. We would highly recommend their services and many thanks to George Flower who has delivered a brilliant service for us.

A

Andrea Gascoigne

Recently won a nice project with the help of BWS, found them easy to work with and will use again.

B

Barry Chapman

We used this company as part of our growth strategy, in that they, and I mean Lauren Moorhouse as their lead, created from scratch a comprehensive Bid Library. This is an excellent process to begin this new phase of our development, to gain more work and raising our branding profile. The whole system, was great to see how it grew into the formidable tool that it is, which we now have at our disposal, with an increase in our confidence to bolster our turnover.

B

B&E Boys

We employed BWS to assist with our bid writing and knowledge management resources. The team were always very professional and flexible in working around our schedules whilst maintaining agreed deadlines. We would recommend BWS to others who are looking for a ‘fresh set of eyes’ on any business development material. We will be working with BWS in the future.

M

Matt Webb

We engaged with BWS to assist with a bid on a civils project and were very pleased with the work they delivered. There was always clear communication and documents were produced within the agreed timeframes and cost. Being the first time working with a bid writing company they immediately put as at ease and gave us confidence that our submission was as strong as possible which gave us the best chance. Thanks to all the team at BWS!

N

Nick Heath

Compass Fuel

We dived into the world of tenders, and Lauren made the process fairly simple for novices like ourselves. Wouldnt hesitate to use their services again. Nick Heath - Compass Fuel

J

Josh Lownsborough

Working with Kyle has been a pleasure , He has been working weekends and evenings to get the job ready in time, His responses are superb and he is a real professional at his job. I hope we win the contract and I will certainly use Kyle again in the future

M

Matt

My organisation has only recently started working with BWS and we have already seen a win! The team are always professional and work around my schedule. We will continue to work with BWS for future bids, thanks BWS team!

T

Tracey Gordon

Excellent, efficient and professional service from Lauren & Rhiannon. Would 100% recommend and will definitely use again.

J

James Bell

Great service. Quick turnaround and well written bid. Fingers crossed for a successful tender outcome.

C

Chris Davy

We used BWS and found them very quick and efficient, well worth using and will do again

A

Anele Griessel

Rhiannon was friendly, listened, and clarified our questions. Thank you very much

M

Mirela Stefan